If you could change the positions of the contestants in American Idol Season 7?
If you could change the positions of the top 12 contestants in American Idol Season 7 from the first person voted off until the winner how would your outcome be?
Mine would be:
1st- Syesha Mercado *Winner
2nd- Michael Johns *Runner Up
3rd- Carly Smithson
4th- David Archuleta
5th- Chikezie
6th- David Hernadez
7th- Ramiele Malubay
8th- Brooke White
9th- David Cook
10th- Amanda Overmeyer
11th- Jason Castro
12th- Kristy Lee Cook
Related Posts:
This is how American Idol 7 should have gone?
american idol 7 - seasons of love (idol gives back)
Top 12 American Idol 7 - Get Ready (Finale)
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Interesting question. I would definitely make some changes since I feel like there were several contestants, Michael Johns and Carly Smithson in particular, who were voted off the show WAY too early. The one position that I would not change in any way, shape, or form is the winner. To me David Cook is the most incredible, amazing, and talented contestant who has ever been on the show and I will be a Word Nerd for life!
But if I were to rearrange the order how they got eliminated it would look like this:
1st - David Cook! *Winner!
2nd - Michael Johns *Runner Up
3rd - Carly Smithson
4th - David Archuleta
5th - Brooke White
6th - Jason Castro
7th - Syesha Mercado
8th - Chikezie
9th - David Hernandez
10th - Ramiele Malubay
11th - Amanda Overmeyer
12th - Kristy Lee Cook
We have very different opinions on most of the contestants but agree that Michael and Carly both deserved to stay around a lot longer than they did. And we both agree that Kristy Lee stayed around FAR too long! Haha.
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
1- would still have David Cook win.
2-Syesha Mercado
3-Carly Smithson.
4-Michael Johns
5-10- I don’t care
11- Kristy Lee Cook
12-Jason Castro
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
This is a really good question.
1- David Cook. I love that man. He deserved to win.
2- David Archuleta. I like him a lot too.
3- Michael Johns. He went home WAY TOO EARLY. Very very awesome.
4- Carly Smithson. Also went home too early.
5- Syesha Mercado. She was good, but didn’t deserve the 3rd spot as much as Carly or Michael.
6- Brooke White.
7- Jason Castro.
8- David Hernandez.
9- Chikezie.
10- Amanda Overmeyer.
11- Ramiele Malubay.
12- Kristy Lee Cook. I think everyone agrees that she should’ve gone first.
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
1st- David Cook
2nd-David Archuleta
3rd- Carly Smithson
4th- Chikezie
5th- Jason Castro
6th- Syesha Mercado
7th- Brooke White
8th- David Hernadez
9th- Michael Johns
10th- Ramiele Malubay
11th- Kristy Lee Cook
12th- Amanda Overmeyer
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
David Cook deserved to win… :]
Brooke White should have been second.
Then Carly Smithsons
Then Amanda Overmeyer
Then David Archuletta
Idc about the others
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Mine:
1st - David Cook as the Winner (America got it right)
2nd - Michael Johns as the Runner Up
3rd - Jason Castro
4th - Syesha Mercado
5th - Carly Smithson
6th - Brooke White
7th - David Archuleta
8th - Chikezie
9th - David Hernandez
10th - Ramiele Malubay
11th - Kristy Lee Cook
12th - Amanda Overmeyer (could not stand this girl.)
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
1. David Archuleta
2. Carly Smithson
3. Syesha Mercado
4. Michael Johns
5. Brooke White
6. Ramiele Malubay
7. Amanda Overmeyer
8. David Cook
9. David Hernandez
10. Kristy Lee Cook
11. Jason Castro
12. Chikezie
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
I think it was right just where they were except I think Michael Johns should have lasted a little bit longer.
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Well, I’m actually fine with the way it ended up. David Archuleta was my fave from the start, but I love David Cook just as much, he was my second fave. So it doesn’t matter to me. I do think Michael Johns and Carly Smithson should have stayed longer. I love everybody else, too, so it really doesn’t matter much to me.
btw, good question!
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
The only thing that I would’ve changed was David Archuleta winning instead of David Cook.
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Ohhh…. Good Question! Haha!
I like Archuleta and Cook! ahaha. I love Archie but I trhink Cook really deserves to win… ;DDD
1st David Cook
2nd David Archuleta
3rd Carly Smithson
4th Michael Johns
5th Brooke White
6th Syesha Mercado
7th David Hernandez
8th Chikezie
9th Amanda Overmyer
10th Ramiele Malubay
11th Jason Castro
12 Kristy Lee Cook
;DDD
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
1st- David cook
2nd- David Archuleta
I wouldn’t change the top 2, they were both awesome and deserved to be in the finals.
I do feel also, Michael Johns and Carly Smithson were GREAT and shouldnt have gone so damn early! Michael was voted off like what? 7th, 8th!? That guy was good. okay, let me continue my list.
3rd-Michael Johns
4th- Carly Smithson
5th- Jason Castro
6th- Syesha Mercado
7th- Brooke White
8th- David Hernandez [that was the male stripper right? lol. he was pretty good]
9th- Ramiel Malubay
10th- Chikezie
11th- Amanda Overmeyer
12th- Kristy Lee Cook
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
the worse season i have seen.
Josiah Leming would have won!!!!!!!!!
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Well would it be A B C
or would it be 1 2 3
you gotta vote
abc
or one twe three.
nearly made a song lol.
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
I agree with the order…
Except Michael Johns should have been there longer.
At least ’til the top 4.
Oh well, The best man won.
&Completely deserved it.
<33
December 23rd, 2009 at 2:20 pm
That is a very intelligent question you’ve asked, I really thought Chikezie, Amanda, Carly and Michael got voted off way too early and that Season 7’s AI was one of the weakest Top 5 contestants they’ve ever had
1st: David Lee Cook
2nd: Carly Smithson
3rd: Michael Johns
4th: David Archuleta
tied for 5th: Amanda Overmyer
tied for 5th: Chikezie
7th: Syesha Mercado
8th: David Hernandez
9th: Ramiele Malubay
10th: Jason Castro
11th: Brooke White
12th: Kristy Lee Cook
I really thought Chikezie, Amanda, Carly and Michael got voted off way too early and that Season 7’s AI was one of the weakest Top 5 contestants they’ve ever had
December 25th, 2009 at 7:13 pm
I agree with the top 2, they were the most experienced and deserved to be in the finale. Post-idol, I’m most impressed with Jason Castro. He’ll be releasing an album under Atlantic Records early next year and from the previews I’ve heard it’s going to be pretty dang good!
1st- David Cook
2nd- David Archuleta
3rd- Jason Castro
4th- Chikezie (loved his upbeat songs)
5th- Brooke White
6th- Michael Johns (I looked forward to his album but was disappointed by it)
7th- Carly Smithson
8th- David Hernandez
9th- Syesha Mercado
10th- Amanda Overmeyer
11th- Ramiele Malubay
12th- Kristy Lee Cook