This is how American Idol 7 should have gone?
Is it just me, or has this season of American Idol been kind of a letdown…? I liked the top 12 people, just not the order they got kicked off in. This is how I feel the voting should have gone:
12: Amanda Overmyer
11: Brooke White
10: Jason Castro
9:David Hernandez
8: Ramiele Malubay
7:Chikezie Eze
6: Kristy Lee Cook
5: Michael Johns
4: Syesha Mercado
And after that….
3: Carly Smithson
2: David Cook
1: David Archuleta
I think Brooke and Jason stayed in waaaaaay too long. A lot of people also thought Kristy Lee Cook did, too, but I think she was a way better singer than those two. I’m good with the top 3 right now (Syesha and the Davids) - I actually like all of them, finally. But some singers overstayed their welcome. Does anyone else feel like this?
Related Posts:
If you could change the positions of the contestants in American Idol Season 7?
Top 12 American Idol 7 - Get Ready (Finale)
American Idol Top 8 - Shout To The Lord (HQ)
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
I agree with you completely! That is how the list should have gone. David Archuleta should win it all. I loved the order you put it in!
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
I agree with you. The order you have is correct. The top 5 can all sing in tune at least.
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
u think so?
i think they should cancel the stupid show.
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
I disagree
but kinda agree sometimes
12 David Archuleta
11 David Hernandez
10 Amanda
9 Ramiele
8 kristy Lee
7 Brooke
6 Carly
5 syesha
4 chikezie
3 David Cook
2 JASON!!!
1 Michael Johns!!!
David A has overstayed his time by a LOoooooooong time… votefortheworst.com agrees with me!
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
In my humble opinion..
12: Chikezie Eze
11. Amanda Overmyer
10: Jason Castro
9: David Hernandez
8: Ramiele Malubay
7: Kristy Lee Cook
6: Syesha Mercado TIE
5: Brooke White TIE
4: David Archuleta
3: Carly Smithson
2: David Cook
1: Michael Johns
The only C.D.s I will ever buy would be Michael Johns or David Cook’s
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
I would definitely have David Cook be first and Michael Johns be second. Carly should be third. David Archuleta always sounds the same and becomes boring. Jason Castro just annoyed me because he always sings the same- definitely should not have been close to the top 4. Amanda should have stayed longer- she was original.
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
Should’ve been:
12. Ramiele
11. Jason
10. David Archuleta
9. Brooke
8. Kristy
7. Amanda
6. Chikezie
5. Carly
4. Michael Johns
And:
3. David Hernandez
2. David Cook
1. Syesha
December 30th, 2009 at 9:33 am
my order is…
12. Kristy Lee (should’ve been Asia’h Epperson)
11. Chikezie (should’ve been Danny Noriega)
10. Amanda
9. David H
8. Ramiele
7. Syesha
6. Brooke
5. Jason
4. Michael
3. Carly
2. David C
1. David A